OST is closed for business but its spirit survives on my blog.

Christopher Hitchens, God is not Great

I picked up Christopher Hitchens’ God is not Great: How Religion Poisons Everything at Schiphol Airport yesterday on my way back to London from the Hague. I’m four chapters in and so far heartily recommend it: nice yellow cover, scathing, articulate and tendentious polemic. I would suggest that this sort of critique of religious belief and practice, not least of Christian religious belief and practice, should be required reading for anyone who aspires to lead the church beyond the intellectual and moral complacency of Christendom.

Like Dawkins’ The God Delusion, the analysis is one-sided and rather lazy at times. His survey of religious conflict in Belfast, Beirut, Bombay, Belgrade, Bethlehem and Baghdad highlights some appalling ironies and injustices but downplays the extent to which religion is exploited by the forces of nationalism and community identity. There is only a grudging recognition that obscure, ordinary people of faith ‘may have contributed to the good of the world’. And Hitchens has to my mind a seriously flawed view of Paul as a misogynist, who expresses ‘both fear and contempt for the female’, and a world-hating apocalypticist, ‘who clearly thought and hoped that time was running out for humanity’.

But it is far too easy for us, living within the protective, soothing, reassuring intellectual bubble of our faith communities, to underestimate the precariousness of our confession, and I think it is essential that we allow ourselves to be reminded from time to time that the church has a very poor historical record, that there is not a shred of evidence to support the premises of our belief system, that it is extremely difficult these days to put forward a defence of religion on rational or ethical grounds, and that there is much about the life and thought of the church today that is at best laughable and worst utterly reprehensible. Hitchens will certainly do that for us.

It seems to me that at the heart of the calling of the church as it emerges from Christendom is the challenge of constructing a way of being in the world, both practically and theologically, that offers a plausible and honest response (not necessarily a direct apologetic) to these powerful and persuasive critiques. The place to start is not the knee-jerk defence of the faith or even the attempt to dissociates ourselves from other bad religions. The place to start is simply in experiencing what it is like to be hit in the solar plexus by the more angry and determined repudiators of religion.

Your rating: None Average: 3 (1 vote)


Re: Christopher Hitchens, God is not Great

As momma said: Honesty is the best Policy.

I’m not sure it could be said better…good job! I hope the church listens.

Re: Christopher Hitchens, God is not Great

I thought Tristram Hunt’s review of Hitchens’ book (which has been out for two years now) was fairly apt. I’m happy to be in the company of non-Christian academics like Hunt, Eagleton and others in relation to the crudities of Dawkins, Dennett and Hitchens. But I haven’t read the book. My holiday reading was William Boyd’s ‘Any Human Heart’ and Hunter Davies’ biography of A.J Wainwright. (I was staying in the southern Lake District last week). Not a theological tome in sight.

Re: Christopher Hitchens, God is not Great

Great review, Andrew. As long as you don’t mind, I’m going to use this for Inside CA.

Re: Christopher Hitchens, God is not Great

Andrew… ah, yes, again, we are to realize that the call to incarnate is the call to allow the incarnate Christ to dwell inside us as the Cosmic Whipping Boy for the world’s anger and the power of sin.

It is hard for all of us to accept that Christ emerges most powerfully from the ground, breathless, with a compressed solar plexus, but with this renewed invitation I uncomfortably assume the position, with some sort of spiritual grin (not unlike the buddha?) knowing that with Jesus, every little thing, is gonna be alright.

Re: Christopher Hitchens, God is not Great

Hitchens is correct when he points to the horrible dangers of faith systems,and their inherant absurdities. However, like all rationalists ….

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.